Midterms: Quick Take

By Mike Koetting November 5, 2026

Well…that was refreshingly clear.

A very large part of the population said “Stop pissing on my boots and telling me it’s raining.”

While an excellent development, plenty of uncertainty ahead.

Immediate Aftershocks

It seems to me the most immediate issues for the country sit with the Republicans in Congress. Two things I worry about are Trump re-escalating in Iran and either or both Alioto and Thomsas resigning.

Regardless of whether they have any principles about the war in Iran, Republicans know that played an outsized role in their shellacking. Although I can’t imagine any enthusiasm for expanding it, their options aren’t great. A War Powers resolution that, in theory, would curtail the ability to wage war has already been passed by the House. It would only take a few Republicans to join with the Democrats to pass it in the Senate. Presumably, however, it would be vetoed. Given the election, maybe there would be enough Republicans to override. It’s not like they are seeing any remaining Trump coattails. J.D. Vance, always the alert opportunist, has already blamed GOP losses on the war.

But it would be messy to implement. Moreover, if Congress did override a veto and Trump simply ignored it, it could lead to a serious Constitutional impasse, even before the new Congress is seated.

Another possible avenue is via the need for a continuing resolution to keep government running. The current CR expires December 11. The issues over Defense spending will be salient. Trump has asked for huge increases in the Defense budget, among other things to finance the Iran war. Trump may try to pass these now, knowing they will have no chance in the new Congress. But there was already considerable Republican concern about these budgets, so it will be interesting to see how this plays out.

On the Supreme Court front, while both Alioto and Thomas have said they do not plan to retire, pressure on them to do so will surely increase. While Republicans would be glad to cement a couple youngsters into those seats, they can surely see far enough ahead to understand that if they do it in this manner, it will raise the odds of Supreme Court term limitation to something close to 100%–and possibly even a change in the size of the Court. Of course, both of those might happen anyway, so maybe they would take their shots now and worry about the long term later.

Consideration of these issues along with the election results again raises in my mind the possibility of a Nixon deal. Namely, Republicans promise Trump and his family immunity if he resigns. It is, however, not clear if there is a Republican leader who has the status to pull this off. Mitch McConnell of two years ago could, but not now.

It is also an interesting question as to how Democrats would respond to such a deal. Proposing this deal in my circle of friends has inevitably led to heated discussions. It seems to me this is a much less attractive deal for Democrats than it was last week.

Then What

There is no shortage of people identifying the problems that Democrats face. They are typically described as struggles between Progressive and Moderates. Others discuss how much attention Democrats should give to impeachments and investigations. I would prefer—with a major exception that I’ll get to in a minute—that Democrats focus very heavily on the things people asked them to fix.

As overwhelming as the election results were, Democrats need to remember that this “Blue-nami” benefited greatly from people who two years ago voted for Donald Trump. To point out that they don’t have a clear political philosophy (or indeed any political philosophy) seems almost redundant. Rather, they have needs. It is very hard to see how these voters will care much at all about impeachments and other activities that to them appear simply as politicians arguing among themselves. Focus instead on things that make a direct difference.

One set of investigations that might, however, be useful is looking at the bold face corruption. No one likes corruption. While corruption gets mentioned in some election analyses I’ve seen, I don’t think most give sufficient credit to revulsion at the epic level of Trump’s grift. According to the last CNBC poll before the election, voter concern about government corruption exceeded all other concerns, even high prices. Multiple other polls found very high levels of concern about Trump’s corruption. A Fox News poll showed voters’ top issue was corruption–even more than inflation. Interestingly enough, the narrative surrounding the chart with this finding does not so much as mention the issue.

I am not sure what the Trumplicans were thinking. Did they expect Americans to simply ignore dozens of scandals, each of which would have ended any other presidency? Did they believe Americans were simply too jaded to care? Perhaps they believed that no matter how bad Trump got, Americans’ dislike of woke culture and progressive governance would always make the Republicans the lesser of two evils.

In any event, people noticed and really didn’t like it.

With that in mind, I think it makes sense for the Democrats to keep up a steady stream of investigations into the business dealing of Trump and his family. I agree there is a discouraging amount of willingness to slough this off with “they all do it.” But, for better and worse, Trump is so brazen that the indifference threshold has been pierced. By all means, keep the spotlight on that. Two months before Orban lost his election in Hungary, Anne Appelbaum suggested that the corruption by Orban and his regime was so open, that a large portion of the population was tying it to the erosion of their life situation. It did in Orban and it is doing so to Trump.

In my next post, I will expand on my ideas for where Democrats should focus and what are the obstacles they will have to overcome.

Campaign Expenses

One more immediate comment on the election. Good lord it was expensive.

OpenSecrets, a non-partisan, non-profit which tracks campaign expenditures, estimates that expenses for federal races alone will exceed $12 billion, not including primaries for federal offices or any state and local elections. I am inclined to agree with David Brooks’ assessment that once you get beyond the level of expenditure that introduces the candidate and their perspectives, further expense has rapidly diminishing returns. It is certain that there are many high-profile races where the candidate spending the most money did not win. For instance, both Paxon and Rogers outspent their opponents and lost. Regardless of effectiveness, I believe this degree of election spending is simply wrong, never mind who spent it.

My primary objection is this spending does not improve the lives of citizens. $12 billion would cover one year of SNAP for about 3.75 million people or a year of subsidized housing for 750,000 to 1 million people. If the choice were put to the populace, I would bet the farm that that they would overwhelmingly—like overwhelmingly, overwhelmingly—chose aid over advertising.

Beyond that fundamental issue, the large amount of money going into elections gives the rich a legal way to curry favor with the people running government. It also creates an environment where, to break through the noise, people compete against the other side to shock and disparage, which has the overall effect of souring people on all politics.

I believe one of the things a Democratic Congress should do is move to limit the amount of expenses for elections. McCain-Feingold was a bi-partisan effort. It could be again. I am not sure how to get around a Supreme Court dedicated to making the world safe for absurd levels of political funding, but there must surely be a way to skin that cat. Virtually every other developed country has strict limits on campaign financing. It makes the world better.

On Balance

The country is so much better where we are than where we were. Even if there is still work to do, we should celebrate. At least for the rest of the week.

Are the American Political Parties Relevant?

By Mike Koetting October 27, 2026

Polling shows that the public support for either political party is limited.

While all kinds of explanations and fixes are proposed, I think the major explanation is that the political parties are mostly irrelevant.

Say What?

To people who pay attention to politics (thank you, loyal readers), the idea is hard to grasp. Our world view is significantly shaped by the familiar duality of American politics: Republicans or Democrats control the Senate, there are Red States and Blue States, governors are either Republican or Democrat. It is hard to imagine the PBS Newshour without the idea of Republican or Democrat.

But truth is, we are a minority of the population. And when you get by the idea of parties as a handy intellectual organizing principle, it’s not clear what’s left.

The Founding Fathers were pretty specific that political parties were a bad idea because they encouraged collaboration that could become undemocratic. But parties nevertheless sprang up within a generation. For most of our history they served as a mechanism by which people of roughly similar political persuasions could organize to capture power for their common ideas. This requires the party to resolve intraparty tensions so as to maintain enough coherence of purpose that even people who were only marginally interested in politics could rally around the brand. It only works for the country if the parties share enough democratic values that they can mitigate differences to accomplish the work of governing.

That process was helped along because the parties provided a second useful function—executing what I call the soft mechanics of elections in a democracy. This involved deciding how candidates happened and under what ground rules they participated.

The Undoing of Parties

Both these functions started to falter in the 1960’s.

For most of the 20th century, Democratic Party identify was maintained by focusing on economic issues that impacted poor and middle-class Whites and simply ignoring the plight of Blacks in the Jim Crow south.  Eventually that became impossible to paper over and a material portion of the Democrat Party abandoned ship. For those who remained, the tension between ideas of equality and economic equity has been a persistent fault line. Today’s division between “woke” Democrats and “moderates” is only the latest example.

Until recently, Republicans were able to present a more coherent façade, but underneath a tension was building because the uber-capitalist sentiment of parts of the party could work only with enough sleight of hand to keep fuzzy the underlying commitment to the wealthy. (It is more than a little ironic that the Gilded Age around the turn of the previous century was mostly undone by Republicans—starting with the Progressive movement of Bob LaFollette, a Republican from Wisconsin, and the trust-busting of Teddy Roosevelt. But Republicans quickly returned to form as the party of governmental restraint, which preeminently meant restraint from getting in the way of capital accumulation.)

It is plausible to argue that the current Republican Party isn’t even a party in the traditional sense. In the previous understanding, the foundation of a party was a collection of people holding principles that, while vague at the edges, was discernible, had some consistency over time, and exercised influences in a shared understanding of the country’s foundational principles. What is currently called the Republican Party has shown time and time again that its loyalty is not to any set of principles but to whatever Donald Trump decides. Capricious tariffs, attacking our historic allies, forgoing any commitment to global democracy, using the forms of law to pursue personal agendas and vendettas, and forgetting any concept of fiscal conservancy. That is no longer a group of people coming together with a common philosophy trying to exercise influence in a democracy. It is a clique devoted to maintaining their position regardless of ideology.

Donald Trump, Jr. made it crystal clear. At the “Stop the Steal” rally on the National Mall six years ago. He said that when it came to people who believed in following the rules and the courts: “This isn’t their Republican Party anymore. This is Donald Trump’s Republican Party.”

The second function of parties, deciding how candidates happened, mostly ended with the advent of direct primaries. These happened because of sentiment that the party hierarchy was picking candidates out of synch with the electorate. While the sentiment was understandable, it is not clear the ramifications were thought out. If parties have no control over the candidates that nominally represent the party, what is the party? And what does it actually represent if individual candidates get to decide what the party stands for?

There is an argument that direct primaries allow party positions to more quickly reflect underlying changes in society than waiting from them to be filtered through a party hierarchy. And that may be an okay thing. I don’t, for instance, think Barack Obama gets elected if it weren’t for direct primaries. But, then again, neither does Donald Trump. For better or worse, direct primaries hollow out the role of parties.

And, of course, in the middle of all this, successive Supreme Court rulings have changed the nature of campaigns by allowing unlimited political donations. (In The American Prospect, Harold Meyerson is referencing the Court as “Supreme Court (R-DC)”.) Not only does this give advantage to those who have unlimited funds, it has also led to special interest groups effectively picking candidates because those groups have infinitely more resources than the political parties. Today, most funding comes via the candidate and the individuals who support them; parties are more dependent on funds from the candidate than vice versa.

Does It Matter?

I can’t make up my mind about this. I am generally opposed to reifying fictions because it causes people to confuse the nature of reality. On the other hand, the idea of parties does serve as a useful organizing principle, even if remarkably imprecise.

There is also the possibility that a party could be re-energized, as Ben Wickler suggests happened in Wisconsin. He argues the secret is all-season, all offices organizing by the party around a broad set of principles toward making government oriented to all the people as opposed to the rich. It has made a difference in Wisconsin over the last several cycles, but we will have to see if that lasts and how the results pay out. At least for the moment, Democrats there, as elsewhere, are benefitting from Republican lack of performance on the core issues around affordability. It will remain to be seen if this can be sustained given that major changes will require more than one or two election cycles and the current electorate is impatient. This is one of the symptoms of people voting around immediate needs absent the kind of overarching philosophy a party could provide.

G. Elliott has been arguing that the swing factor in the last several elections is low-information voters (operationalized as voters who don’t know which party controls Congress). They are almost entirely focused on immediate economic issues. In the absence of some party getting a durable enough majority to make real changes, majorities will simply bounce from one party to the other as low-information swing voters remain angry. A differentiating factor would be if one party (Democrat, Republican or other) has a vision that meets people’s perceived needs as well as a convincing argument about why the journey will take a while and what are markers along the way. It will also need enough intermediate, tangible results that illustrate progress to get durability. In this regard, I am very curious to see if Mamdani can sustain enthusiasm over a longer period as he tries to achieve major changes.

I have some sympathy with Lee Drutman’s Breaking the Two Party Doom Loop, which argues that the sharp nature of our partisan warfare is making it excruciatingly difficult to actually govern. But is that split really a result of the two parties or is the division of the polity into those two groups disguising the true nature of the problem—which to me is the inordinate influence of the top 5% of the economy. This is aggravated by a social information network that dispenses decontextualized information and emotions without having to meet with other people and agree on communal responses.

I strongly suspect that the relative disinterest of the population to pollical parties is largely a function of the general sentiment that government does not work for them and can’t be trusted to do the right thing. In 1958, 73% of the population said they trusted government to do the right thing most of the time. By 2025, that number had shrunk to 17%. After all, if you can’t trust government to do the right thing, why care about which party is running it?

It is also unclear to me whether the sharpness of the current political world is caused more by the political parties or by the breakdown of the political parties. Historically, political parties—by their need to build some degree of internal cohesion—were more likely to blunt differences. They were also more able to fashion compromises between the parties because they had some overlapping values. With the loss of party power to pick candidates in the primaries, there is a tendency for more extreme arguments to take over. As that happens, it becomes more difficult for parties to broker compromises. I remain convinced a majority of the Republican Congressional delegation knows how bad Donald Trump is for the nation. But they feel powerless against the cabal organized to support Trump—whose interest in traditional Republican principles only accidentally and periodically coincides with what they are doing. If there were a sense that traditional Republican principles actually had leverage, more Republicans would be willing to stand up.

Where Does It Go?

Good question.

Given the current miasma, I hope more state parties take up the challenge posed by Ben Wickler to reinvigorate parties at the state level. At the same time, I am eager to see more experiments with ranked-choice voting and proportional representation to see where they are going. They might provide a structural fix that is less dependent on the circumstances of particular state parties.

In the meantime, it seems to me that in their current configuration, political parties are more spectators than actors in a world-class political mess.

Missing Life Expectancy

Mike Koetting October 13, 2036

I recently ran across an article that argued that the United States had far too many premature deaths. The article called it a crisis. This echoed an article from a couple years ago by Matt Yglesias that America’s shorter life expectancy should be a priority because, as he put it, “Dying is bad.”

Whether it’s a crisis or not, it is clear that life expectancies in the U.S. lag behind those of other developed countries and, over time, seem to be falling further behind. In 1980, the U.S. had the 14th highest average life span of countries with populations above 1 million. It has slipped steadily since then, now ranking 38th among countries with more than 1 million people.

For the most part, life expectancy in the U.S. has continued to increase over this period, just not as fast as the rest of the developed world. The aggregate differences are not large—U.S. average life expectancy was about 79 whereas, say, European countries were typically two to four years higher. The differences between an average life expectancy of 79 and 82 may not seem like a critical difference in the course of long lives. But these numbers disguise what’s going on. In fact, longevity at older ages has generally improved in relation to other countries. The difference in the overall rates arises from higher mortality among young and middle-age people–people who could be expected to live longer and whose shorter lives make a difference.

The following chart compares projected mortality rates before the age of 40 in the US versus an average of high-income countries.

Continue reading “Missing Life Expectancy”

Midterm Thoughts

By Mike Koetting September 29, 2025

Today is five weeks from the election day…although, in fact, the election is well under way in many states. Increasingly, “election day” could be better characterized as “disclosure day”—an announcement of the results that have been building for weeks.

I have been reading polls, poll analytics and poll pundits. From all this reading, I see the experts converging on one idea: “Well, we’ll just have to see.”

There is, of course, much more thought behind this and all concede that there is plenty of reason for Democratic optimism and Republican concern. But the overall composition of the next Congress will come down to a whole lot of individual races that are hard to predict. The hardening of the country into Red and Blue (most of it reinforced by gerrymandering to make small majorities larger majorities) structurally dampens the likelihood of change.)

Continue reading “Midterm Thoughts”

A Letter I Would Like to Send to Senator Thune

By Mike Koetting September 23, 2026

Like many Americans, I am frustrated at the unwillingness of the Republican Congress to rein in Donald Trump. I think his actions have gone well beyond matters of normal policy differences.

I want Republicans to actually provide a rationale for their inaction. I submitted a proposed op-ed to several newspapers in the form of a letter to Senator Thune asking him how they could ignore what was happening.

None printed it. My questions, however, remain unanswered. So, imagining there is any way I could get through to John Thune, I ask again.

The Honorable John Thune:

Continue reading “A Letter I Would Like to Send to Senator Thune”

Republicans Aren’t Cutting Health Care Costs—They’re Just Shifting Them

By Mike Koetting September 1, 2026

As various cuts to Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act (ACA) take effect, it becomes clear that they will substantially reduce the health care options available to millions of Americans.

This is awful.

But this note is not focused on the harm it does people impacted directly, rather on the fact that the entire premise of these cuts is fundamentally a lie. Despite any rationalizations by Republicans, the cuts in Medicaid and the ACA included in the Republicans’ budget bill are less reductions in health care costs and more shifts in who pays. In this case, it moves costs from the most wealthy (by reducing their taxes) to the rest of us (who pick up the pieces in various ways.) It is a stealth “tax” increase on those not specifically benefited from Republican Budget Bill.

If the country is ever going to have an honest discussion about health care, we need to understand the actual dynamics.

Continue reading “Republicans Aren’t Cutting Health Care Costs—They’re Just Shifting Them”

Fighting Adaptation to Reality

By Mike Koetting August 18, 2026

My last post argued that since serious environmental mitigation was politically implausible (at least for the time being), we needed to step up our efforts to adapt to changing environmental conditions. I am not talking about projections of what might happen. I am talking about responding to realities that are facing us here and now.

This post expands on that theme. I start with a few micro-case studies that illustrate some of the challenges. Then I try to place that in a larger focus.

Continue reading “Fighting Adaptation to Reality”

Fifty Years of Environmental Avoidance

By Mike Koetting August 4, 2026

I recently ran across an article contending that the 1972 Limits to Growth projections about environmental threats were on track. That reminded me that when these were first published, my friend Rick Casey, then at the National Catholic Reporter, commissioned me to write a review. Although long since moved on, he was able to track down the review for me.

Turns out, it held up fairly well. But, before that….

Continue reading “Fifty Years of Environmental Avoidance”

Trump’s Last Speech Was More Telling Than We Are Recognizing

By Mike Koetting July 21, 2026

In the Sixties, there was a bumper-strip that said: “What if they had a war and nobody came?” Donald Trump’s address to the country last week was like that. Half of the major networks didn’t even bother to carry this windbag of previously debunked claims. The next day, virtually the entire country shrugged at the old recitations. There is a temptation to leave it there.

But there was actually something so unusual about this address that it demands more attention than what the country gave it. The speech was built around, and enthusiastically pointed to, a large stack of declassified analyses of possible election fraud. But that “evidence,” claims notwithstanding, showed that our elections were remarkably safe. Some foreign actors fiddling around the edges and a handful of potentially ineligible immigrants voting but mostly a long and careful summary that shows our elections have not been threatened.

In other words, he posted and called attention to his own speech’s rebuttal. This is so beyond normal, had we not been anesthetized by the endless stream of lies and absurd claims, we might have paid more attention.

Continue reading “Trump’s Last Speech Was More Telling Than We Are Recognizing”

Deterioration in Political Discourse Leads to Deteriorated Thinking

By Mike Koetting July 7, 2026

A recent Pew Center poll found Republicans were much more skeptical of emerging climate problems than Democrats. I wasn’t at all surprised—and I’ll bet you’re not either.

My second thought was to wonder why this should be. After all, if I asked a random sample of Chicagoans whether the White Sox will make the playoffs this year, I would not expect to see a marked difference in response by political parties. And while there are no end of uncertainties, the factual bases for arguments about environmental predictions are much stronger than predicting baseball outcomes. But here we are with political leaning outstripping other considerations.

Wasn’t Always So

In the 1970’s, as we first started to understand the problems we had unleased, the environment was a totally bi-partisan concern. Richard Nixon enthusiastically presided over the creation of the EPA. By 1997, there was starting to be a spread between Democrats and Republicans on core climate issues—whether climate warming was happening and whether it was caused by humans—but it was only a modest 8%. By 2024, that gap had climbed to 35%.

Continue reading “Deterioration in Political Discourse Leads to Deteriorated Thinking”